Dear Mr. Albert Pujols,
You sir, are a god.
You are the greatest hitter in baseball right now. And, your are making a good case of being one of the best ever.
You are also in the process of negotiating a contract extension with the St. Louis Cardinals--my favorite team. And this negotiation is splitting my loyalties.
On the one hand, with the knowledge that you are the greatest, I think you should get a ton of money. Seriously, if we could get a scale and put 2000 lbs of hundred dollar bills on it, that would be yours, in my estimation. It's my impression this would far exceed the 3o million a year for 10 years that you are rumored to want, but I'm not sure. My point is, you have been a great player for a long time, playing under a contract that the most club-friendly person might call "modest". And you've seemed like a good person through it all. Team leader, unselfish player, you've been everything on the field. And off, it seems. In fact, you've set up a charity that helps people living with Down syndrome.
In short, I think the Cardinals should give you your money. And I think the Cardinals can afford to pay you. And if they can't, it's because they didn't plan ahead enough.
I know you probably didn't know this Mr. Pujols, but I'm currently in law school and as part of my training, I've been studying the negotiation process in one of my skills class. So, when I saw the report that the Cardinals believe you would not accept a trade in the middle of the season, part of me smiled. I saw this as a smart bargaining position. It says to the team, either you pay me now, or you have to try to pay me when the Yankees and Red Sox bring there wallets to the table--you won't get the consolation prize of prospects. It's a strong move. It's probably the right move for you, sir.
Here's my problem though. I rationally see your position and acknowledge your right to get paid. But. I also am a life-long Cardinal fan, and this is not something that is entirely rational. Should you not get the contract you deserve and leave, well, I don't know what I'll do. Over the last decade, I have grown to love watching you play baseball. I have really enjoyed it. And if you go somewhere else, I don't know how I'll react. That's not exactly true--if you go to the Cubs, I will have to seek professional help. And professional strength medication. But, barring that, I'm going to be torn. I can't see myself following you and becoming a fan of another team. It's unthinkable, really. So. I would still follow your career. I would still root for you to do well. I would cheer you if/when you came through Minneapolis. But, it would definitely be a parting for us. I could state it another way, I suppose, but this is what it boils down to.
I know you can't take this into your calculation. You have to make a business decision. You have to make a decision that's good for your family. And I wish you luck. And I really do hope you get the money you deserve.
I just also hope you can do it with the Cardinals.
All the best,
joe